Post-Publication Discussion

JURNAL ILMIAH M-PROGRESS JOURNAL PUBLICATION POLICY

PUBLICATION ETHICS

Post-Publication Discussion

Post-publication discussion provides an opportunity for readers and researchers to exchange views, raise questions, and communicate relevant feedback concerning articles published in the journal.

POST-PUBLICATION DISCUSSION

JURNAL ILMIAH M-PROGRESS

 

Editorial Office and Journal Management

Guidelines for Discussion

1. Relevance to the Published Article

Comments and discussions should relate directly to articles published in the journal. Contributions should address the article's findings, methodology, interpretation, or implications for further research.

2. Scientific and Constructive Feedback

Discussions should be based on academic reasoning, evidence, and appropriate references. Authors and readers are expected to communicate respectfully and provide constructive contributions to scholarly dialogue.

3. Publication Integrity and Transparency

Contributions should maintain academic integrity, accurately represent the published work, and disclose relevant information where appropriate. Unsupported allegations and misleading statements should be avoided.

4. Editorial Review and Response

The editorial team may assess submitted comments for relevance, scholarly merit, and compliance with journal policies. Authors may be invited to respond when appropriate.

5. Ethical and Respectful Communication

All participants should respect the principles of academic ethics, confidentiality where applicable, and professional communication throughout the discussion process.

Discussion supported by evidence

Meaningful post-publication discussion helps clarify research findings, identify opportunities for further investigation, and strengthen the quality of scholarly communication.

The journal encourages constructive academic engagement while maintaining editorial independence, publication ethics, and the integrity of the scholarly record.

All discussions and responses are subject to editorial consideration and the applicable policies of the journal.